Skip to main content
  • Wealth management
  • Asset management
  • Wealth management
  • Asset management
  • MyRathbones login
  • Financial Planning login
  • Donor Advised Fund login
Home
  • Who we help
    Who we help

    We help a wide range of clients invest well so that they can focus on what matters

    Who we help
    • Individuals and families

      Focusing on you and your individual goals

    • Business owners and entrepreneurs

      Helping turn the success of your business into financial security for your family

    • Financial advisers

      Working with you, for your clients.

    • Charities

      Helping charities invest in line with their mission and values

    • Professional partners

      We work with lawyers, accountants and other professionals.

  • Our services
    Services

    See our wide range of services tailored for your needs

    Our services
    • Investment management

      Looking for someone to create an investment portfolio for you?

    • Wealth management

      Our combined investment and planning service for a holistic approach to your finances

    • Financial planning

      Need help reorganising your finances and planning for the future?

    • Asset Management

      Looking to invest in a fund? See our full range

    • Tax and trust

      Helping you pass on your wealth, manage a trust or gift to charity

    • Greenbank sustainable investing

      Looking for investments that align with your values? See our sustainable investment options

  • About us
    About us

    A top 3 UK wealth manager with roots dating back to 1742

    About us
    • Careers

      Learn more about what it’s like to work at Rathbones, and search our current vacancies

    • Corporate governance

      Explore our reports and accounts which ensure we comply with the UK Corporate Governance Code

    • Investor relations

      Find the Rathbones plc financials, investment case and key events

    • Media centre

      Read the latest Group news

    • Our purpose

      Our driving purpose is to help more people invest well, so they can live well

    • Responsible business

      We believe in doing the right thing for our clients and for others too

  • Insights
    Insights

    Read the latest news and market commentary from our specialists

    Insights
    • Financial planning

      Explore a range of topics effecting your finances, from retirement planning to the latest legislative changes

    • Investing

      Read about the key investment themes effecting global markets

    • Podcasts

      Listen to our specialists in one of our podcasts: Inspired sounds, Inspired minds, or Financial planning unlocked

    • Responsible investing

      Explore our articles, reports and events on Responsible Investment

  • Contacts
    Contacts

    Whether you have a question about our services, or need to talk someone specific, we can help

    Contacts
    • Our offices

      Find your local Rathbones office. We have 21 across the UK and Channel Islands.

    • Our people

      Find the contact details for your Rathbones team by searching our people’s directory.

    • Let's talk

      Our team will be in touch to help you book a no obligation consultation with an adviser.

    • Other contacts

      Need to contact us about something else? Here you'll find all the options

Let's talk

Search

Decision making in education, health, and social care matters

3 November 2022

James Pantling-Skeet of Boyes Turner LLP has contributed an article on the issue of service-led, rather than needs-led, decision making in education, health and social care matters. An issue which is likely to have a significant impact on the support available to a protected client from statutory services.

Article last updated 22 July 2025.

Professional deputy standards

The Office of the Public Guardian (OPG) Professional Deputy Standards require a Property & Affairs Deputy (Deputy) to identify, review and secure all benefits or public funding that a protected client may be entitled to receive. In addition, a Deputy must review at least annually the position regarding public funding.

The OPG’s intention here is simple, namely, to set an expectation that the Deputy will maximise the funding available to meet P’s needs. After all, if P can secure any public funding to assist with the high costs of meeting education, health and social care needs, it is imperative that such funding is secured.

The impetus to secure statutory funding is inevitably greater where the costs of meeting P’s needs are significant. In some cases, the litigation claim may have settled on a split liability basis meaning statutory funding is required to meet P’s needs over their lifetime. If a funding stream is not subject to means-testing rules, there is clearly a further advantage to P.

Service-led rather than needs led

The difficulty many Deputies face, however, is overcoming the obstacles to securing the right amount of statutory support without being equipped to navigate the complexities of the legal framework across education, health and social care law.

Often applications for support are met with significant resistance by statutory services. Public bodies may make decisions which are not sufficient to meet the entirety of P’s needs and further the particular support identified (for example, an Integrated Care Board’s choice of residential care placement or a Local Authority’s preferred school placement) may not be in P’s best interests.

Funding shortfalls and budget constraints are continually increasing, leading to a clear trend in service-led, rather than needs-led, decision-making across education, health and social care law. By this, I mean decision making which suits the tightly constrained budgets of public bodies, rather than decisions based on P’s needs and the provision required to meet any needs identified.

To ensure that decisions are made in P’s best interests, it is imperative that the Deputy is aware of the process for challenging decisions, the often very short timescales in which action must be taken to protect P’s best interests, and the constraints of their authority without Court of Protection (COP) approval, pursuant to the decision in Re ACC.

Current issues

There are so many issues to be aware of and there is simply not enough time within this article to explore them all.

In the context of health funding, we have recently seen significant reform. From 1 July 2022, Clinical Commissioning Groups (CCGs) were replaced with Integrated Care Boards (ICBs) with the passing of the Health and Care Act 2022. The intention behind the reform is to build a better, more integrated, care system, drawing upon the benefits of collaboration between services.

Whilst it is too early to identify whether the legislation is likely to meet its objectives, what we have seen is an increase in the number of high-cost health-funded care packages being reviewed by ICB’s Equity & Choice Panels (ECPs). In many cases, ECPs are resulting in decisions to re-assess need with a view to identifying all the possible ways in which P’s needs may be met.

The decision to re-assess may have been validly made, however, it is vital that the Deputy works with the case manager and those on the ground to properly prepare for the re-assessment process. A substantial amount of evidence is likely to be required to demonstrate that the status quo should be maintained. It is imperative to demonstrate to the ICB through any re-assessment process the complexity of P’s needs and that P’s specific needs necessitate the continuation of a costly package in order. Further evidence may be required to support an appeal through the ICB’s established appeals process, or possibly other forms of public law challenge such as Judicial Review.

Many children and young people are being wrongly ‘screened out’ of Continuing Care for Children and Young Persons because there is often a misunderstanding of the difference between this funding stream and NHS Continuing Healthcare for Adults. There is an increasing push back between Continuing Care teams and Children’s Social Care teams regarding what falls within their respective remits, which can be difficult for the Deputy and family to navigate.

Some ICBs are also advising families of policies which prevent the family from leaving a child or young person with a health-funded professional in the house without parental supervision. The legality of such policies requires careful consideration.  

In the world of special educational needs provision and social care, Panel decision-making in the context of resource allocation is increasingly problematic. In some instances, this approach may not be lawful and detrimental to P’s best interests. The problem with Panels is that often families and relevant professionals are not permitted to attend and make representations. In addition, it is not clear how the Panel is constituted, what evidence has been considered as part of any decision-making process and how a decision has been reached.

Often when a copy of the Panel’s meeting minutes and/or relevant policy is requested, many report that such documentation does not exist. There is a real lack of transparency in this area and in an appropriate case, the Deputy may need to take swift action to challenge a Panel’s decision to negate the potential need for a more lengthy and costly process, such as an appeal to the Special Educational Needs & Disability Tribunal (SENDIST). Given the current average length of a SENDIST appeal, it is imperative that we identify alternative ways to challenge and resolve issues where appropriate to ensure that P’s best interests are protected.

There are so many other current issues to be aware of in this complex area, however, it is not possible to cover them all in this article. The key is to keep abreast of this ever-evolving area given the significant impact it is likely to have on the day to day life of many protected clients.

What should Deputies do?

My advice to all Deputies is to be as proactive as you can.

Make sure you are in regular contact with the case manager and P’s family regarding education, health and social care issues.

If you do not already do so, build into your Annual Deputyship visit and check-ins with family regular discussions regarding these matters.

If you know an issue is on the horizon, plan so that there is time to collate the evidence required to maximise the prospects of securing the high-cost package or residential school placement that meet P’s needs and is in P’s best interests. Particularly in special educational needs cases, there are often lengthy wait times for independent expert reports and as such you need to factor these in to minimise any adverse impact on P.

Be aware of the strict time limits for challenging the decisions of public bodies and factor this into the need to consider whether a Re ACC application may be required to ensure that you have the authority to act when required.

Finally, equip your teams with the information required to plan, spot and act upon issues when they arise through training.

For further information view Rathbones’ specialist personal injury and Court of Protection services.

Popular Articles

The cover illustration of Investment Insights Q3 2025

1 min

7 July 2025

Investment Insights Q3 2025

Investment Insights Q3 2025
9341_multi-asset_webinar_cm.jpg

1 min

14 May 2025

Multi-Asset Webcast | May 2025

Multi-Asset Webcast | May 2025
Black wire-framed spectacles, a white calculator and a gold pen lie on a light blue accounting ring-binder folder

6 mins

6 May 2025

Review of the week: End of an era

Review of the week: End of an era
Most Read
  1. Investment Insights Q3 2025

  2. Multi-Asset Webcast | May 2025

  3. Review of the week: End of an era

  4. Weekly Digest: A trail of debris

  5. Don't bet the house: Why the Golden Age of UK property investment is over

Let's talk

Ready to start a conversation? Please complete our enquiry form, we look forward to speaking with you

Enquire
Rathbones Logo
  • Important Information
    • Modern Slavery Statement
    • Important Information
    • Complaints
    • Privacy
    • Accessibility
    • Climate reporting
    • Cookies
    • Update cookie preferences
    • Sitemap
  • Important information 2
    • Financial Services Compensation Scheme
    • Banking services
    • Consumer duty manufacturer request for information
    • Financial Ombudsman Service
    • Interest Rates
    • Keeping you safe
    • ScamSmart
    • Status of our websites
Address

Rathbones Group Plc
30 Gresham Street
London
EC2V 7QN

© 2025 Rathbones Group Plc
Incorporated and registered in England and Wales.
Registered number 01000403

Follow us
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • X
  • Youtube

The value of your investments and the income from them may go down as well as up, and you could get back less than you invested.