Skip to main content
  • What We Do
    • Investment Management
    • Financial Planning
    • Trust and Tax
    • International investment
    • Greenbank - Ethical and sustainable investment
    • Asset Management
    • PERSONAL INJURY AND COURT OF PROTECTION
  • Our Clients
    • Individuals and Families
    • Charities
    • Financial Advisers
    • Professional INTERMEDIARIES
    • Entrepreneurs
  • About Group
    • About us
      • Rathbones Group
      • Saunderson House
      • Our Purpose
      • Partnerships
      • Our Offices
      • Events
        • All events
        • Financial awareness courses
      • Our story
    • Responsibility
      • Responsible Business
      • Responsible Investment
      • Climate Reporting
      • Reports
    • Investors
      • Investor Relations
      • Reports and Results
      • Shareholder Information
      • Investment Case
      • Financial Calendar
      • Share Price Information
      • Contacts and Offices
    • Governance
      • Group executive committee
      • Board Committees
      • Directors
      • Policies
      • Articles of association
      • Corporate Governance
    • Media Centre
    • Careers
      • Vacancies
      • Investing in our people
      • Working at Rathbones
      • Your Career
      • Early Careers
    • Our People
  • RATHBONES
  • Insights
    • Knowledge and Insight
    • Rathbones Review Winter 2025
    • Know Where Life Can Take You
    • Insights
      • Investment insights
      • Investment Reports
        • Polls apart: Navigating America’s divisive election
        • Investing for the next decade
        • Peace of mind in a dangerous world
        • Building a more sustainable future
        • The Cloud Revolution
      • Financial Planning Insights
      • Financial Wellbeing Research
      • Responsible investment insights
      • Earth Convention
    • Podcasts
      • Financial Planning Unlocked
      • Inspired Minds
      • Inspired Sounds
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Our Offices
  • Client Portals
    • About our client portals
    • MyRathbones Login
    • Rathbones Financial Planning Online Login
Home Home

Search

  • What We Do
    • Investment Management
    • Financial Planning
    • Trust and Tax
    • International investment
    • Greenbank - Ethical and sustainable investment
    • Asset Management
    • PERSONAL INJURY AND COURT OF PROTECTION
  • Our Clients
    • Individuals and Families
    • Charities
    • Financial Advisers
    • Professional INTERMEDIARIES
    • Entrepreneurs
  • About Group
    • About us
      • Rathbones Group
      • Saunderson House
      • Our Purpose
      • Partnerships
      • Our Offices
      • Events
        • All events
        • Financial awareness courses
      • Our story
    • Responsibility
      • Responsible Business
      • Responsible Investment
      • Climate Reporting
      • Reports
    • Investors
      • Investor Relations
      • Reports and Results
      • Shareholder Information
      • Investment Case
      • Financial Calendar
      • Share Price Information
      • Contacts and Offices
    • Governance
      • Group executive committee
      • Board Committees
      • Directors
      • Policies
      • Articles of association
      • Corporate Governance
    • Media Centre
    • Careers
      • Vacancies
      • Investing in our people
      • Working at Rathbones
      • Your Career
      • Early Careers
    • Our People
  • RATHBONES
  • Insights
    • Knowledge and Insight
    • Rathbones Review Winter 2025
    • Know Where Life Can Take You
    • Insights
      • Investment insights
      • Investment Reports
        • Polls apart: Navigating America’s divisive election
        • Investing for the next decade
        • Peace of mind in a dangerous world
        • Building a more sustainable future
        • The Cloud Revolution
      • Financial Planning Insights
      • Financial Wellbeing Research
      • Responsible investment insights
      • Earth Convention
    • Podcasts
      • Financial Planning Unlocked
      • Inspired Minds
      • Inspired Sounds
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Our Offices
  • Client Portals
    • About our client portals
    • MyRathbones Login
    • Rathbones Financial Planning Online Login
Home

Search

Investing in armaments: has anything changed?

With ongoing global conflicts such as the war in Ukraine, where new technology is redefining the battlefield, we look at the controversial issue of investment in defence companies.

2 October 2024

Breadcrumb

  1. Home
  2. Knowledge and Insight
  3. Investing in armaments: has anything changed?

Article last updated 3 October 2024.

Geopolitical events such as the Russian invasion of Ukraine and conflict between Israelis and Palestinians makes the world seem a more uncertain place than has been the case for most of this century.  

So, it’s perhaps not surprising that one of the most common questions our charity clients have asked us over the past 12 months is whether they should be continuing to exclude defence companies in their investments. It’s undoubtedly a controversial subject and trustees will, of course, have very different views and lived experiences – differences that we fully respect.

Revisiting inherited decisions

Trustees sometimes find they inherit historic investment decisions and policies made by their predecessors and this alone may be a good reason for revisiting the thinking behind that strategy.

Some charities have historically taken an essentially pacifist stance to investment in defence companies – and the reasons for excluding such companies from their portfolios remain just as relevant today as they have ever been.

However, most charities which have excluded armaments have done so for a variety of other reasons. For example, many that oppose investment in defence companies essentially take the view that armaments are designed to kill people, which makes it inappropriate to profit from the manufacture and sale of weapons, irrespective of who uses them and where. That resolve may only have been strengthened by depressing figures from the Peace Research Institute in Oslo, showing numbers of global conflicts and battlefield deaths from 1945 to 2023, which reveals there’s been a marked increase in both in recent years.

Another argument against investment in armaments is the international trade in arms. Defence companies not only sell weapons to our own government and those of other democracies but also to states involved in internal repression, human rights abuses or international aggression. One contributing factor to this has been the decades-long lifespan of armaments. Weapons sold in what seem like acceptable circumstances can later be used with unintended consequences – such as a British-built warship being used by the Argentine navy in the 1982 Falklands War.  

Other factors that have made charities anxious about investment in armaments include the large incidence of bribery and corruption in the international arms trade, and then specific concerns around certain types of weapons such as nuclear weapons or anti-personnel landmines.

Defending our way of life

More recently, some charities have found themselves wrestling with the question of whether investment in armaments can be justified on the basis that they help to provide the security that enables our way of life– and can therefore be a ‘just’ use of weapons.  

Against the backdrop of a major land war in Europe involving Russia’s military might, this debate is a hot topic, with high-profile figures arguing that defence companies are ethical investments. Grant Shapps, former Secretary of State for Defence has said, for example: “Investment in defence is the morally right thing to do, without which the atrocious activities of tyrants like Putin would go unchallenged and undeterred.”

New forms of warfare

Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has also seen the nature of battle itself transformed – in particular with increasing use of drones, which in many cases are very cheap, mass-produced civilian drones.

Although not viewed as warfare in the traditional sense, cyber-attacks are now being used to disrupt a country’s infrastructure, with reported attempts by Russia to sabotage the Czech rail system being just one example.

The result is governments turning to cyber security companies to provide protection. Over the past few years, Microsoft, Amazon, Google and Oracle have all received multi-billion-dollar contracts from the Defense Department in the USA.  

Such developments have led some charity investors to reflect on what is captured by defence spending: if they have exclusions relating to the proportion of spending that comes from military exposure – typically set at 5% to 10% – should they start to think about technology companies as potential exclusions?

Has anything changed?

So, has anything changed in the past few years? Certainly, the Russian invasion of Ukraine has made us all think more about the role that armaments manufacturers play in ensuring the security of our way of life. As part of that, many charity trustees will no doubt reflect on their investment policies and whether they should continue to exclude defence companies.

Of course, the security role of defence companies has always been there – and it’s useful to bear in mind that many defence investment exclusions date back to the Cold War period, when the existential threat was just as severe as it is now.

The technology of warfare is undoubtedly changing and that may mean a rethink about what qualifies as a company involved in defence activities but, overall, many of the factors underlying the analysis of defence companies are still the same today as they’ve always been.

These may be uncertain times, and that might change the mood of debate around armaments but, for the time being, talking to our clients, we’ve found that the majority of charities that have previously excluded defence companies have not changed their policies.

The content contained in this document is for information purposes only and does not constitute formal advice or a recommendation to purchase any product or service. You should always take appropriate advice from a professional, who has made an evaluation at the point of investing.  

If you would like to speak to us about your investment needs, please contact your Rathbones investment manager or visit our contact us page.

Popular Articles

image of shipping containers in a shipping yard from above
4 April 2025

Trump’s tariffs: how should investors respond?

Stock markets have reacted badly to the worse than expected news on US trade policy. We favour a more conservative asset allocation in response – but it’s possible to be too gloomy.

Find out more

5 mins

Black wire-framed spectacles, a white calculator and a gold pen lie on a light blue accounting ring-binder folder
6 May 2025

Review of the week: End of an era

Arguably the best investor of all time has decided to retire at the end of the year. Meanwhile, UK interest rates are forecast to fall in a bid to prop up the economy.

Find out more

6 mins

Golden crown on black background
7 April 2025

Review of the week: The emperor's new tariffs

Markets are tumbling fast in response to US tariffs that will upend global trade. Perhaps more dangerous than the policy itself is just how silly it makes the administration look.

Find out more

9 mins

MOST READ
  1. Trump’s tariffs: how should investors respond?

  2. Review of the week: End of an era

  3. Review of the week: The emperor's new tariffs

  4. Review of the week: Gloves off?

  5. A spring statement on fiscal discipline

Let's Talk

Ready to start a conversation? Please complete our enquiry form, we look forward to speaking with you.

Enquire
  • Important Information
    • Modern Slavery Statement
    • Important information
    • Complaints
    • Privacy
    • Accessibility
    • Climate Reporting
    • Cookies
    • Cookie Preferences
    • Sitemap
  • Other information
    • Financial Services Compensation Scheme
    • Financial Ombudsman Service
    • Scam Smart
    • Keeping our clients safe
    • MiFID II Cost and Charges FAQ
    • Statement of Cost and Charges
    • Banking Services
    • Interest Rates
    • Consumer Duty Manufacturer Request for Information
Address

Rathbones Group Plc
30 Gresham Street
London
EC2V 7QN

© 2025 Rathbones Group Plc
Incorporated and registered in England and Wales.
Registered number 01000403

Follow us
Facebook Instagram LinkedIn Twitter Youtube

The value of your investments and the income from them may go down as well as up, and you could get back less than you invested.