Skip to main content
  • What We Do
    • Investment Management
    • Financial Planning
    • Trust and Tax
    • International investment
    • Greenbank - Ethical and sustainable investment
    • Asset Management
    • PERSONAL INJURY AND COURT OF PROTECTION
  • Our Clients
    • Individuals and Families
    • Charities
    • Financial Advisers
    • Professional INTERMEDIARIES
    • Entrepreneurs
  • About Group
    • About us
      • Rathbones Group
      • Saunderson House
      • Our Purpose
      • Partnerships
      • Our Offices
      • Events
        • All events
        • Financial awareness courses
      • Our story
    • Responsibility
      • Responsible Business
      • Responsible Investment
      • Climate Reporting
      • Reports
    • Investors
      • Investor Relations
      • Reports and Results
      • Shareholder Information
      • Investment Case
      • Financial Calendar
      • Share Price Information
      • Contacts and Offices
    • Governance
      • Group executive committee
      • Board Committees
      • Directors
      • Policies
      • Articles of association
      • Corporate Governance
    • Media Centre
    • Careers
      • Vacancies
      • Investing in our people
      • Working at Rathbones
      • Your Career
      • Early Careers
    • Our People
  • RATHBONES
  • Insights
    • Knowledge and Insight
    • Rathbones Review Winter 2025
    • Know Where Life Can Take You
    • Insights
      • Investment insights
      • Investment Reports
        • Polls apart: Navigating America’s divisive election
        • Investing for the next decade
        • Peace of mind in a dangerous world
        • Building a more sustainable future
        • The Cloud Revolution
      • Financial Planning Insights
      • Financial Wellbeing Research
      • Responsible investment insights
      • Earth Convention
    • Podcasts
      • Financial Planning Unlocked
      • Inspired Minds
      • Inspired Sounds
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Our Offices
  • Client Portals
    • About our client portals
    • MyRathbones Login
    • Rathbones Financial Planning Online Login
Home Home

Search

  • What We Do
    • Investment Management
    • Financial Planning
    • Trust and Tax
    • International investment
    • Greenbank - Ethical and sustainable investment
    • Asset Management
    • PERSONAL INJURY AND COURT OF PROTECTION
  • Our Clients
    • Individuals and Families
    • Charities
    • Financial Advisers
    • Professional INTERMEDIARIES
    • Entrepreneurs
  • About Group
    • About us
      • Rathbones Group
      • Saunderson House
      • Our Purpose
      • Partnerships
      • Our Offices
      • Events
        • All events
        • Financial awareness courses
      • Our story
    • Responsibility
      • Responsible Business
      • Responsible Investment
      • Climate Reporting
      • Reports
    • Investors
      • Investor Relations
      • Reports and Results
      • Shareholder Information
      • Investment Case
      • Financial Calendar
      • Share Price Information
      • Contacts and Offices
    • Governance
      • Group executive committee
      • Board Committees
      • Directors
      • Policies
      • Articles of association
      • Corporate Governance
    • Media Centre
    • Careers
      • Vacancies
      • Investing in our people
      • Working at Rathbones
      • Your Career
      • Early Careers
    • Our People
  • RATHBONES
  • Insights
    • Knowledge and Insight
    • Rathbones Review Winter 2025
    • Know Where Life Can Take You
    • Insights
      • Investment insights
      • Investment Reports
        • Polls apart: Navigating America’s divisive election
        • Investing for the next decade
        • Peace of mind in a dangerous world
        • Building a more sustainable future
        • The Cloud Revolution
      • Financial Planning Insights
      • Financial Wellbeing Research
      • Responsible investment insights
      • Earth Convention
    • Podcasts
      • Financial Planning Unlocked
      • Inspired Minds
      • Inspired Sounds
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Our Offices
  • Client Portals
    • About our client portals
    • MyRathbones Login
    • Rathbones Financial Planning Online Login
Home

Search

Johnny-come-Januaries

The new year always drives well-intentioned yet poorly sustained get-fit-quick schemes. That leads multi-asset fund manager Will McIntosh-Whyte to wonder about the durability of subscription service customers in a downturn.

24 January 2020

They are back. Bright-eyed and bushy-tailed. Full of new-year enthusiasm at the thought of the new healthy, happier versions of themselves. We’ve all seen them – we’ve all been one – Johnny-come-Januaries.

Or at least they were back. As we enter the second half of January the local gym is already much quieter as the dark, alcohol-free (and meat-free?) evenings weigh on the soul. The draw of the sofa and the latest box-set only gets stronger after Blue Monday.

Interestingly, there weren’t quite as many Johnnies (or Janeys) in my gym this year. Perhaps the supposed health and wellness craze isn’t as prevalent as some commentators claim? I’d argue rather that traditional gyms like mine, with their 12-month contracts, are being disrupted. And not necessarily by the ‘high-tech’ US sporting goods companies with their snazzy £2,000 exercise bikes, iPads strapped to the front, charging you £40 per month for the privilege of taking online classes. Most people simply want flexible gym memberships. Why sign up for 12 months when you know you’re a bit busy in February, on holiday in March and then summer is nearly here...

So if I was trying to invest in a health and wellness theme, which option would I choose? The subscription gym, the flexible gym, or the tech exercise bike company? Well, the answer is probably none. The subscription gym is being disrupted; the flexible gym may be enjoying growth, but it can’t rely on those earnings continuing even a month from now; and I struggle to see genuine barriers to entry for rival exercise bike companies. Equally, I remember vividly my dad’s ’90s rowing machine gathering dust in the garage. It’s probably still there now.

There are two principles highlighted by this theoretical investment choice. Firstly, as an investor you may be onto a fantastic investment theme, but that doesn’t mean there’s always a sure fire way of playing it or picking the winners. Secondly, beware the subscription revenue story. Of course, recurring revenues are appealing to companies and investors (who will pay up for the privilege). Less so for consumers – I’m sure many of us have fallen foul of subscriptions we signed up to and forgot to cancel, even though we stopped going to that gym sometime in 2017. But nowadays the volume of subscriptions that people are accumulating has mushroomed: Netflix, Fitness First, Spotify, iCloud, Audible, Headspace, Playstation Plus, Dollar Shave Club, Zipcar, Candy Crush, Amazon Prime, NowTV, CreditExpert, HelloFresh and Oddbox, And lest we forget MoviePass, which would ‘buy’ you a free cinema ticket every day for the compelling cost of $9.95 a month (it bought the tickets full price); who wouldn’t subscribe to that!  As you might suspect, that didn’t end well.

At the end of day, there’s only so much wallet share to go around. While we all know the structural difficulties retail faces, perhaps part of its problem has been that, as the smart phone opened up our wallets to so many other avenues (gaming, taxis, food delivery, ecommerce, gambling, along with the aforementioned), people simply have less money to go out and spend on the physical high street. Or don’t need to – it’s all there in their pocket.

Often we hear the argument that consumers won’t cancel these subscriptions because “they are only £5/£10 a month”. But they soon add up and when people go through lean times, the purse strings get tightened. When that happens, not a few subscriptions will have to fall by the wayside, which is why I’m wary of overpaying for fair-weather subscription services that might find themselves dispensable when times get tough.

So I’m binning off the gym for a night on the sofa, and will be getting out my banking app to check for rogue subscriptions!

   

Let's Talk

Ready to start a conversation? Please complete our enquiry form, we look forward to speaking with you.

Enquire
  • Important Information
    • Modern Slavery Statement
    • Important information
    • Complaints
    • Privacy
    • Accessibility
    • Climate Reporting
    • Cookies
    • Cookie Preferences
    • Sitemap
  • Other information
    • Financial Services Compensation Scheme
    • Financial Ombudsman Service
    • Scam Smart
    • Keeping our clients safe
    • MiFID II Cost and Charges FAQ
    • Statement of Cost and Charges
    • Banking Services
    • Interest Rates
    • Consumer Duty Manufacturer Request for Information
Address

Rathbones Group Plc
30 Gresham Street
London
EC2V 7QN

© 2025 Rathbones Group Plc
Incorporated and registered in England and Wales.
Registered number 01000403

Follow us
Facebook Instagram LinkedIn Twitter Youtube

The value of your investments and the income from them may go down as well as up, and you could get back less than you invested.