Navigating the fossil fuel divestment debate

Rathbone Greenbank’s engagement manager Matt Crossman looks at the growing financial case, as well as the ethical reasons, for divesting from fossil fuels.

An increasing number of individuals and institutions are divesting from fossil fuels, and the financial case is growing in addition to the ethical reasons for reducing carbon footprints. For an adviser with clients looking to divest, it’s important to analyse the arguments for and against and consider the impact on financial goals.

How you define divestment dictates your available responses. At its most basic level, divestment is the full or partial disposal of specific stocks or sectors. But it’s important to define the limits and scope of divestment – and the rationale behind any decision.

This may be limited to the worst case examples, such as companies involved in the extraction of thermal coal or tar sands. But the scope of this decision may also extend further down the fossil fuel value chain to include companies engaged in exploration for new sources of fossil fuels, such as fracking.

Historically, divestment decisions have been based on the environmental and social harm caused by the extraction and use of fossil fuels. But strong financial arguments are now being made, inspired largely by the Carbon Tracker Initiative’s influential series of reports, based on the concept of a global carbon budget.

This analysis sets a constraint on the amount of carbon that can be safely burned to minimise the chance of exceeding 2C of global warming by 2050.  It presented one of the first cogent arguments that a ‘carbon bubble’ exists in the valuations of fossil fuel companies. A reduction in the value of a company’s stated reserves, due to the risk of those assets becoming ‘stranded’, could have an adverse materially affect on its balance sheet and valuation.

How can you respond?

Investors have several options available – the choice is not binary – that can form part of a spectrum of actions.  First, there is the option of full divestment from oil and gas producers and coal mining companies. This is relatively straightforward to execute, but can have implications for portfolio performance relative to mainstream market indices.  Next, there is selective divestment from the most financially vulnerable companies, such as those involved primarily in exploration, or in projects with the highest carbon intensity or the most extreme environmental impacts, such as tar sands.  

Alternatively, an extension of this approach uses a ‘best of sector’ strategy that considers the full spectrum of social and environmental risks facing companies and only invests in those demonstrating a consistent ability to manage those risks.

And finally, for many, engagement with fossil fuel companies, which power modern life and provide much of the energy we all use every day, can be a powerful agent for change. There is an argument that the engaged investor who remains invested is well-placed to conduct a constructive dialogue with company management to achieve a change of direction in the fight against climate change.

And a wider aim of divestment – beyond selling holdings in fossil fuel companies – is to encourage the creation of a low- carbon economy through reallocation of capital.

What are the financial implications?

This is an important question, not just for those facing calls for divestment, but for all seeking to implement aspects of ethics or sustainability within their investment portfolios. And fortunately, it’s not a choice between achieving your financial objectives and investing ethically – you can do both. 

Read more about Rathbones’ recent event discussing the challenges of fossil fuel divestment.

Rathbone Greenbank Investments, Rathbones’ dedicated ethical and sustainable investment team, offers a range of solutions to balance financial and divestment objectives. 

 

Important legal information

This area of the site is for professional advisers

Please read this page before proceeding, it explains certain legal and regulatory restrictions applicable to the distribution of this information. It is your responsibility to inform yourselves of and to observe all applicable laws and regulations of the relevant jurisdiction.

This section of the website is directed only at investment advisers and other financial intermediaries who are authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA).

The information provided in this site is directed at UK investment advisers only and must not be circulated to private clients or to the general public. It does not constitute an offer to sell, or solicit an offer to purchase any investments by anyone in any jurisdiction in which such offer or solicitation is not authorised or in which a member of the Rathbone Group is not authorised to do so.

I confirm that I am an investment intermediary authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. I have read and understood the legal information and risk warnings below:

Important Information (Terms and Conditions)

The information contained on this site is believed to be accurate at the date of publication but no warranty of accuracy is given and the information is subject to change without notice. Any opinions or estimates included herein constitute a judgement as of the date of publication and are subject to change without notice. Furthermore, no responsibility is accepted for the accuracy of any information contained within sites provided by third parties that may have links to or from our pages.

Rathbone Investment Management Limited ("RIM") is authorised by the Prudential Regulation Authority and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority and the Prudential Regulation Authority. Registered Office: Port of Liverpool Building, Pier Head, Liverpool L3 1NW. Registered in England No 01448919.

In accordance with regulations, all electronic communications and telephone calls between Rathbones and its clients are recorded and stored for a minimum period of six months.

The information provided in this site is directed at UK investors only. It does not constitute an offer to sell, or solicit an offer to purchase any investments by anyone in any jurisdiction in which such offer or solicitation is not authorised or in which a member of the Rathbone Group is not authorised to do so.

In particular, the information herein is not for distribution and does not constitute an offer to sell or the solicitation of any offer to buy any securities in France and the United States of America to or for the benefit of United States persons (being resident in the United States of America or partnerships or corporations organised under the laws of the United States of America or any state, territory or possession thereof).

In order to comply with money laundering and other regulations, additional documentation for identification purposes may be required.

Rathbones shall have no liability for any data transmission errors such as data loss, damage or alteration of any kind including, but not limited to, any direct, indirect or consequential damage arising out of the use of services provided or referred to in this website.

Past performance should not be seen as an indication of future performance.

The value of investments and the income from them can fall as well as rise and you may not get back the amount originally invested, particularly if your client does not continue with the investment over the longer term.

Changes in the rate of exchange between currencies may cause the value of an investment to go up or down.

Interest rate fluctuations are likely to affect the capital value of investments within bond funds. When long term interest rates rise the capital value of units is likely to fall and vice versa. The effect will be more apparent on funds that invest significantly in long dated securities. The value of capital and income will fluctuate as interest rates and credit ratings of the issuing companies change.

Tax levels and reliefs are those currently applicable and may change and the value of any tax advantage will depend on individual circumstances.

Investing in emerging markets or small companies may be potentially volatile, as these investments are high risk.

The design, text and images are owned, except as expressly stated by members of the Rathbone Group. They may not be copied, transmitted, displayed, performed, distributed, licensed, altered, framed, stored or otherwise used in whole or in part or in any manner without the written consent of Rathbones except to the extent permitted and under the procedures specified in the copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988, as amended and then only with notices of Rathbones' rights.

Rate this page:
No votes yet

We’d love to hear your feedback

Please help us improve and shape our future services and products by taking a short survey.