Skip to main content
  • What We Do
    • Investment Management
    • Financial Planning
    • Trust and Tax
    • International investment
    • Greenbank - Ethical and sustainable investment
    • Asset Management
    • PERSONAL INJURY AND COURT OF PROTECTION
  • Our Clients
    • Individuals and Families
    • Charities
    • Financial Advisers
    • Professional INTERMEDIARIES
    • Entrepreneurs
  • About Group
    • About us
      • Rathbones Group
      • Saunderson House
      • Our Purpose
      • Partnerships
      • Our Offices
      • Events
        • All events
        • Financial awareness courses
      • Our story
    • Responsibility
      • Responsible Business
      • Responsible Investment
      • Climate Reporting
      • Reports
    • Investors
      • Investor Relations
      • Reports and Results
      • Shareholder Information
      • Investment Case
      • Financial Calendar
      • Share Price Information
      • Contacts and Offices
    • Governance
      • Group executive committee
      • Board Committees
      • Directors
      • Policies
      • Articles of association
      • Corporate Governance
    • Media Centre
    • Careers
      • Vacancies
      • Investing in our people
      • Working at Rathbones
      • Your Career
      • Early Careers
    • Our People
  • RATHBONES
  • Insights
    • Knowledge and Insight
    • Rathbones Review Winter 2025
    • Know Where Life Can Take You
    • Insights
      • Investment insights
      • Investment Reports
        • Polls apart: Navigating America’s divisive election
        • Investing for the next decade
        • Peace of mind in a dangerous world
        • Building a more sustainable future
        • The Cloud Revolution
      • Financial Planning Insights
      • Financial Wellbeing Research
      • Responsible investment insights
      • Earth Convention
    • Podcasts
      • Financial Planning Unlocked
      • Inspired Minds
      • Inspired Sounds
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Our Offices
  • Client Portals
    • About our client portals
    • MyRathbones Login
    • Rathbones Financial Planning Online Login
Home Home

Search

  • What We Do
    • Investment Management
    • Financial Planning
    • Trust and Tax
    • International investment
    • Greenbank - Ethical and sustainable investment
    • Asset Management
    • PERSONAL INJURY AND COURT OF PROTECTION
  • Our Clients
    • Individuals and Families
    • Charities
    • Financial Advisers
    • Professional INTERMEDIARIES
    • Entrepreneurs
  • About Group
    • About us
      • Rathbones Group
      • Saunderson House
      • Our Purpose
      • Partnerships
      • Our Offices
      • Events
        • All events
        • Financial awareness courses
      • Our story
    • Responsibility
      • Responsible Business
      • Responsible Investment
      • Climate Reporting
      • Reports
    • Investors
      • Investor Relations
      • Reports and Results
      • Shareholder Information
      • Investment Case
      • Financial Calendar
      • Share Price Information
      • Contacts and Offices
    • Governance
      • Group executive committee
      • Board Committees
      • Directors
      • Policies
      • Articles of association
      • Corporate Governance
    • Media Centre
    • Careers
      • Vacancies
      • Investing in our people
      • Working at Rathbones
      • Your Career
      • Early Careers
    • Our People
  • RATHBONES
  • Insights
    • Knowledge and Insight
    • Rathbones Review Winter 2025
    • Know Where Life Can Take You
    • Insights
      • Investment insights
      • Investment Reports
        • Polls apart: Navigating America’s divisive election
        • Investing for the next decade
        • Peace of mind in a dangerous world
        • Building a more sustainable future
        • The Cloud Revolution
      • Financial Planning Insights
      • Financial Wellbeing Research
      • Responsible investment insights
      • Earth Convention
    • Podcasts
      • Financial Planning Unlocked
      • Inspired Minds
      • Inspired Sounds
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Our Offices
  • Client Portals
    • About our client portals
    • MyRathbones Login
    • Rathbones Financial Planning Online Login
Home

Search

In process we trust

A strong investment process is what gets you through ragged markets without making hasty, terrible decisions. But have you actually got a process, or is it simply a bunch of preferences?

3 February 2022

The first few weeks of 2022 have definitely been a challenge. It is quite possible the next few months could be as well, as discussed in our latest episode of The Sharpe End podcast, ‘Hike club’. It doesn’t matter how many corrections you experience, they are always extremely uncomfortable, even a bit frightening.

As you lay awake in the early hours of the morning searching for inspiration and solace, there’s a danger of overthinking things. If you’re not careful, you read more comments from economists, strategists, commentators and your peers, who all seem to have called the correction and are doing better than you. This road leads to paranoia and the feeling that you must take action, any action. Now known as doing a Boris.

This is when your investment process is so important. What if, however, your investment process isn’t actually an investment process? What if it’s just a statement of preferences, which anchor you to your personal views?

A preference for process

Earlier in my career I was a fund buyer, so I guess you might say I am a gamekeeper turned poacher. One thing that used to really make me cross was when a fund manager told me I shouldn’t expect them to outperform their benchmark if their investments were currently out of favour. Now I can absolutely understand this over the short-term and I was happy to back a manager who could express a compelling thesis to support their long-term strategy. I was less sympathetic when a manager underperformed year in, year out based purely on a set of long-held, unshakable beliefs. My job was to determine whether the manager sitting in front of me is the former or the latter.

So what is the difference between an investment process and a set of preferences? For me, an investment process is a set of self-governing rules and disciplines that protect the fund manager – and ultimately their clients – from any emotional or irrational response to periods of market turbulence or underperformance when the ‘noise’ is dialled up to 11.

Examples include position sizing limits, sell disciplines, buying triggers, risk concentration limits and selection criteria for liquidity or business fundamentals, all of which complement longer-term strategy. These will not be hard limits in the prospectus but self-imposed rules to fall back on when under pressure. I use these all the time as they really restrict you from that herding instinct that is so compelling at times of stress. In better times they also protect you from FOMO (fear of missing out).

Investment processes that state no investing in a sector or a country or a type of asset class are not processes, but a list of manager preferences. That is a totally legitimate position to take. I do it also. However, it is a set of beliefs, not a process. These preferences are an investment decision not a portfolio construction framework. Therefore, I would argue, these beliefs need to be challenged regularly by the fund managers themselves, their chief investment officers and their investors.

I fundamentally believe that fund managers do need time to allow their strategies to play out, otherwise you end up endlessly chasing past performance and locking in underperformance. The world keeps changing after all and fund managers need to retain a degree of humility to accept this and be open to change. Confidence is good, arrogance not so, and arrogance with complacency is absolutely toxic.

Thirty years ago, I would never have entertained the possibility of the US 30-year Treasury bond yielding less than 5%. Two years ago, I would not have entertained the possibility of it going back above 5% for many, many years. And now? While a 5% plus Treasury yield still seems unlikely, I am entertaining the chance. Anchoring can make you look stupid.

In my experience fund managers who acknowledge their own human failings and build a set of rules around themselves to guard against these potential weaknesses tend to enjoy longevity of outperformance. That’s good for their careers but also good for their investors.

Tune in to The Sharpe End — a multi-asset investing podcast from Rathbones. You can listen here or wherever you get your podcasts. New episodes monthly.

 

Let's Talk

Ready to start a conversation? Please complete our enquiry form, we look forward to speaking with you.

Enquire
  • Important Information
    • Modern Slavery Statement
    • Important information
    • Complaints
    • Privacy
    • Accessibility
    • Climate Reporting
    • Cookies
    • Cookie Preferences
    • Sitemap
  • Other information
    • Financial Services Compensation Scheme
    • Financial Ombudsman Service
    • Scam Smart
    • Keeping our clients safe
    • MiFID II Cost and Charges FAQ
    • Statement of Cost and Charges
    • Banking Services
    • Interest Rates
    • Consumer Duty Manufacturer Request for Information
Address

Rathbones Group Plc
30 Gresham Street
London
EC2V 7QN

© 2025 Rathbones Group Plc
Incorporated and registered in England and Wales.
Registered number 01000403

Follow us
Facebook Instagram LinkedIn Twitter Youtube

The value of your investments and the income from them may go down as well as up, and you could get back less than you invested.